Chapter 1360: Irrefutable

The eyes of the court were refocused on Cai Shengnan.

She looked serious, looking directly at Mrs. Xing, unable to tell what she was thinking.

Mrs. Xing whispered nervously: "Lawyer Cai, what do you mean? When did I try to murder Mrs. Song?"

She is still used to calling Song Jinning Mrs. Song. Although Song Jinning has left the Huo family now, she still can't change her words.

"Don't you?" Cai Shengnan tilted his head and looked at Mrs. Xing with his hands behind his back, "Then why don't you take good care of Mrs. Song? Let her live in a room that is getting narrower and more crowded, don't talk to her, and leave her alone all year round Alone in the attic?"

These are Luo Jialan's "mental abuse" of Song Jinning mentioned in Gu Nianzhi's indictment.

Mrs. Xing called out to Zhuang Tianqu: "How can you blame me?! I am a caregiver! A domestic service worker! The master asked me to do these!"

Gu Nianzhi immediately followed up: "You mean, these are all Luo Jialan, no, Huo Jialan asked you to do them?"

Cai Shengnan glanced back at her, "Lawyer Gu, I'm the one who's asking questions now, can you stop interrupting when we're talking?"

Gu Nianzhi smiled, "Then, can Attorney Cai stop yelling 'objection' when I'm questioning?"

Cai Shengnan: "..."

"You can't do it, can you?" Gu Nianzhi said earnestly, "Actually, we are all here to find out the truth of the matter. I know that Lawyer Cai is willing to defend Luo Jialan because you believe she is not the murderer, right?"

Now it was Cai Shengnan's turn to be puzzled.

Gu Nianzhi, what kind of operation is this?

Is she going to defect? Stop defending Song Jinning?

Gu Nianzhi continued calmly: "So when I prove to Lawyer Cai and the court that Luo Jialan really tried to murder Ms. Song Jinning, you won't defend her, right?"

"Of course not!" Cai Shengnan objected subconsciously, "Luo Jialan is my client, no matter what she does..."

As soon as the words came out of his mouth, Cai Shengnan knew something was wrong.

She quickly glanced at the four military personnel in the gallery.

Sure enough, they frowned and looked very dissatisfied with her.

In fact, this is understandable legally.

As a lawyer, Cai Shengnan, when she chooses to defend Luo Jialan, no matter whether Luo Jialan is guilty or innocent, she will defend her to the end. This is the professional ethics of this profession.

As for Luo Jialan's guilt or innocence, it was not the lawyer who had the final say, but the court.

But Gu Nianzhi singled out this matter like this, and it didn't sound so fair.

In fact, the most correct answer should be that she believed that Luo Jialan was innocent, so she chose to defend her.

She couldn't say that no matter whether Luo Jialan was guilty or not, she would defend her.

"No matter what she does, Lawyer Cai will defend her? - So what Lawyer Cai really means is that even if Luo Jialan is the real murderer, you have to defend her to the end, right?" Gu Nianzhi set her up again. language trap.

This is how Gu Nianzhi set up a language trap for her.

Cai Shengnan collected himself, forcibly pulled his thoughts back from Gu Nianzhi's interruption, turned around and continued to ask Mrs. Xing.

"Sister-in-law Xing, you just said that the master asked you to do it. May I ask who is the master you mentioned? Is this person in court?" Cai Shengnan turned his body to the side and stopped blocking Mrs. Xing.

Mrs. Xing's eyes slipped over to Luo Jialan.

Cai Shengnan followed her gaze, "It was Luo Jialan, no, Miss Huo Jialan asked her to do this? ——Sister-in-law Xing, before you answer yes or no, I want to remind you that you are testifying in court If your testimony is not true, you will be charged with perjury."

"Objection. The defendant's lawyer threatened the defense witness." Gu Nianzhi lazily raised his hand, actually speaking for Mrs. Xing.

Mrs. Xing glanced at Gu Nianzhi in surprise, then at Luo Jialan, carefully recalling the situation at that time.

After a while, she said: "This man is not in court."

"Oh? Who is that person? A man? A woman?" The smile on Cai Shengnan's lips was faintly visible,

The attitude softened, and the tone of speech can be said to be very inducing.

Gu Nianzhi frowned.

Could it be that Cai Shengnan's purpose was not to blame Aunt Xing for his intention to kill, but to still target Huo Guanchen?

To be honest, Gu Nianzhi never believed that Huo Guanchen had the intention of killing Song Jinning.

Yes, Huo Guanchen is a scumbag, what he did to his seriously ill wife is simply not human affairs.

But it doesn't mean that he wants Song Jinning's life.

If Cai Shengnan still wanted to use Huo Guanchen as a scapegoat, Gu Nianzhi wanted to see if Cai Shengnan had any concrete evidence to show.

Just now Gu Nianzhi had already denied that Huo Guanchen was the murderer, and also refuted Cai Shengnan's evidence.

If Cai Shengnan wanted to bring Huo Guanchen in again, he had to have new evidence.

Gu Nianzhi looked at Cai Shengnan and Mrs. Xing more intently.

In the end, Mrs. Xing actually said: "...it's Miss Bai, that is, Bai Jinyi who has already been sentenced."

"Did she ask you to do this?" Cai Shengnan excitedly asked, "Tell me specifically, what did she ask you to do?"

Mrs. Xing said honestly: "Miss Bai said that Mrs. Song will forget the events of the previous day every day, so give her more familiar things and put them by her side to help her recover her memory."

— so this is why her room is getting more and more crowded, and there are more and more things in the room?

"Also, Miss Bai said that Mrs. Song suffered a serious brain injury and was afraid of light and noise, so we usually dare not talk to her."

— so that's why they didn't talk to her, left her alone in the attic, and gave her cold violence?

While listening, Gu Nianzhi slandered and was very surprised.

It turns out that Bai Jinyi is the real target of Cai Shengnan's blame game? !

I have to say that Cai Shengnan was quite accurate in finding this target.

Gu Nianzhi had mixed feelings in his heart, silently looking in Cai Shengnan's direction.

If what Mrs. Xing said is true, then Luo Jialan can really be released without charge.

Because Bai Jinyi was indeed Song Jinning's attending psychiatrist at the time, and before she was convicted last year, Gu Nianzhi had ridiculed her for "practicing medicine without a license" and was a swindling Mongolian doctor.

So these arrangements were all made by Bai Jinyi. Luo Jialan, like Mrs. Xing and Mrs. You, just obeyed, and Luo Jialan's suspicion was almost cleared.

Gu Nianzhi looked at Luo Jialan with a complicated expression, and suddenly found that Luo Jialan raised his head and glanced at her quickly.

Then, Luo Jialan raised one corner of her lips, showing a half-smile.

This provocative look was like pouring cold water on Gu Nian's head, making her wake up suddenly.

No, in Cai Shengnan's interrogation just now, there was something vague, which not only misled Mrs. Xing, but even everyone in the courtroom.

Even a vigilant person like Gu Nianzhi was almost fooled.

Thinking of Bai Jinyi's once lofty and clean-eyed appearance, it's hard for Gu Nianzhi to imagine that she would talk to Mrs. Xing and Mrs. You like this...

In an instant, Gu Nianzhi had already thought of Cai Shengnan's sloppy eyes, and was ready for the content of the question.

At this time, Cai Shengnan raised a big smile and said to the judge: "Your Honor, it can be seen that this matter has nothing to do with my client, it was purely done by Bai Jinyi alone."

"Bai Jinyi was convicted of murdering Luo Xinxue last year. In my opinion, we also missed her one charge, that is, attempting to murder Ms. Song Jinning. My client is completely innocent."

Cai Shengnan said categorically, ended his questioning of Mrs. Xing, and said, "Your Honor, I want to call the next witness."

Gu Nianzhi raised his hand and said calmly, "Wait a minute. Your Honor, I have something to ask Mrs. Xing."

Cai Shengnan had cross-examined the prosecution witness Huo Guanchen just now, and now it was Gu Nianzhi's turn to cross-examine the defense witness Mrs. Xing.

The judge nodded, "The prosecution lawyer can start questioning."

Gu Nianzhi walked up to the witness stand, and only asked one sentence: "Sister-in-law Xing, what you said just now was ordered by Ms. Bai. May I ask, did Ms. Bai say these words to you 'personally'?"

Gu Nianzhi emphasized the word "personal mouth" and explained, "I asked her if she said it personally, meaning that, like us, we are together face to face, talking to you, and explaining how you want to take care of Song Jinning."

Cai Shengnan's heart skipped a beat, and he said in a drawn-out voice, "Bai Jinyi is in charge of Ms. Song Jinning's physical condition. Of course they listen to Bai Jinyi. What's the problem?"

She doesn't believe that Gu Nianzhi can see the language barrier she set up...

Gu Nianzhi didn't look at her, but just stared at Mrs. Xing closely, not letting go of any chance she had to exchange eyes with Cai Shengnan.

"Sister-in-law Xing, please think carefully about how Bai Jinyi asked you to take care of Ms. Song like this?" Gu Nianzhi pointed again.

Mrs. Xing's eyes flickered, she dared not speak, and took a quick look at Cai Shengnan.

Gu Nianzhi understood, and before Cai Shengnan could speak, he quickly said, "Sister-in-law Xing, do you know what the crime of perjury is?

"According to the criminal law of our country, the crime of perjury is punishable by a fixed-term imprisonment of not more than three years; if the circumstances are serious, a fixed-term imprisonment of not less than three years but not more than seven years.—Do you really want to go to prison?"

"No, no! I don't want to go to jail!" Mrs. Xing waved her hands quickly, and hurriedly confessed: "Miss Bai didn't say these words to us personally. Miss Bai basically didn't talk to us directly. These words came from Miss Bai and Huo Miss said, Miss Huo passed it on to us."

That's about the same.

Gu Nianzhi raised a smile, "How do you know that Miss Bai asked Miss Huo to tell you?"

"Because that's what Miss Huo said!"

"Miss Huo? Which Miss Huo? Is she in court?" Gu Nianzhi glanced at the court.

Mrs. Xing stretched out her finger, timidly pointing at Luo Jialan who was sitting on the dock, "...that's her, she's in charge of Mrs. You and me, and it's she who ordered us to do things, but she said, it's all Miss Bai's doctor's order."

Both she and Mrs. You have a professional license to take care of special mentally ill patients, and they attach great importance to the word "doctor's order".

"So, Luo Jialan actually ordered you all directly, right?" Gu Nianzhi further emphasized, "She said it was Bai Jinyi's doctor's order, but Bai Jinyi never said these words in front of you, did she?"

Mrs. Xing shook her head and said: "Miss Bai is a busy person. She doesn't have much time to come to Huo's house. After she comes, she will mostly be with Mr. Huo. When she talks to Mrs. Song, she drives us out. The two were talking in the room."

Gu Nianzhi nodded, this was probably the time when Bai Jinyi used the clichés, letters, and handwriting from Song Jinning, who was insane.

So even though Luo Jialan was the mastermind in the murder of Song Jinning, even if Bai Jinyi was not an accomplice, he was an accomplice.

Gu Nianzhi turned to look at Cai Shengnan, pointed at Luo Jialan and said to her, "Lawyer Cai, now the truth is revealed. Your client used the excuse of 'doctor's order' to commit murder. The evidence is conclusive and irrefutable!"

※※※※※※※※※※※※※※※※※※※※

This is today's first update: Chapter 1360 "Irrefutable".

It's December again when the monthly ticket doubles at the end of the month.

A certain cold has always been in a complicated mood about the double monthly ticket month~~~

Let's still get used to it, double the monthly ticket, three shifts a day.

The second update at 1:00 pm, and the third update at 8:00 pm.

I try to update it as much as possible, can you vote for the major general with the guaranteed monthly ticket?

Thank you!

╰(*°▽°*)╯.