Chapter 2175 Big Discussion
"What is a crime?" When Zaicang was solving the case, the superiors were still arguing about the method of using killers to solve the case.
Although from the perspective of saving money, everything in the warehouse is very beautiful, but from an ethical perspective, using murderers to solve crimes is definitely unacceptable to ordinary people. If it is exposed, I am afraid that I will be scolded by the public.
So before the masses know the truth, the top management must come up with an excuse. This requires scholars to discuss and demonstrate that using criminals to solve crimes is reasonable and in line with the historical process.
Now the higher-ups are asking scholars to debate. Scholars who support killer detectives believe that criminals who break through the bottom line of human morality are the most primitive state of human beings. It is with this primitive state that human beings stand out from the beasts.
"What is crime? Crime is the infringement of the interests of others for personal gain. But from a historical perspective, the history of mankind is the history of crime, but the crime model is that most people can infringe on the interests of a small number of people for their own benefit. Constantly sacrificing the small The interests of some people are the history of mankind. So I think we can not only use extremely evil criminals to handle cases, but also use extremely evil criminals to rule the country." "Because these people will sacrifice a small number of people without mercy and can be decisive in history. People who make judgments at the expense of the few and gain the support of the majority are called heroes.”
"Nonsense, the hero will indeed sacrifice the minority, but it does not mean that he does not care about the minority. Making such a decision is an act of desperation at the time, not because the hero has no moral bottom line." Another scholar retorted.
However, scholars who support the killer detective are not worried at all: "But you have to admit that both sides still have similarities, and the results are the same. If the humanistic feelings of the heroes are taken away, a small number of people will be eliminated for the sake of social progress. Isn't the ruling method the "ideal world" that countless philosophers flock to; isn't the ruler who only makes correct decisions and is not affected by moral interference the "philosopher king"? "So I think these murderers have a very big influence?" Those who study value, especially the kind of murderers who can complete major cases without changing their expressions, are certainly unpardonable crimes for individuals, but they are precious treasures for all mankind. "
Hearing him actually say that a cold-blooded killer is equal to the 'Philosopher King', many scholars glared at him.
But as a ruler, sometimes you do need to be ruthless. Only in this way can you maintain the progress of society.
"This guy is really hateful." The girl also heard their discussion and hated the scholar who supported the killer. But even the experts couldn't refute it, and the girl certainly didn't have the knowledge to overturn the other party's argument.
"Actually, it's not that these experts can't refute it, it's just that empty talk about morality is not very convincing. After all, morality only stabilizes social order most of the time, and when society is in turmoil, strong people are needed to turn the tide. Not to mention the current situation between countries and collectives In competition with the collective and between individuals, morality is definitely not a necessary condition for victory, cold-blooded decision-making is.”
"Is he really right?"
"It can't be said to be right, it just depends on what you believe. After all, human beings are still developing, and no one knows what will happen in the future. He said that cold-bloodedness is higher than morality, which is only a manifestation of certain stages in history, not Throughout history, there are many tyrants in history, and there is no praise for tyrants, let alone what will happen in the future?" Dulan guided slowly.
The girl opened her eyes wide, but had no answer.
At this time, people who support the killer have proposed a future, which is to let the murderer rule the world, and use the murderer's lack of mercy to make judgments and sacrifice a few people, so as to quickly promote the operation of the world.
Of course, to achieve this, it must rely on the development of technology, and it cannot only rely on the brain of one murderer. It must also have the brains of at least two hundred brutal murderers forming a Bai Naohui, so that a relatively fair judgment can be made. But having only cold-blooded killers is not enough.
To be virtuous, one must also be virtuous.
Once we know the goal, we still need a method of operation. How can we judge who should be sacrificed and who should continue to contribute to society? This requires assistance from high technologies such as genes and mind detection. A certain characteristic of human beings must be tested to complete the judgment, rather than just relying on the killer's words.
In fact, many TV movies have such settings. For example, "Minority Report" has a way to predict other people's crimes. There are also common sci-fi settings of genetic selection, or "Psychometer" can measure everyone's genes. psychological index.
Only with this kind of science and technology and specific operations can the concept of "killers rule the country" be established.
It is precisely because of this screening mechanism, coupled with a ruthless ruler, that society can run. Rather than having ruthless rulers, social development can be completed, otherwise there would not be so many tyrants in history.
Duran told the girl: "This person's words make sense, but he forgot that which tyrant in history was not more cruel than the killer, and which tyrant cared about Bai Xiaosheng's life and death? But in the era of tyrants, did society progress rapidly? No, so it is not the killers who determine the operation of human society. With the progress of human society, the current saintly bitches and white lotus have become stumbling blocks to social progress, so everyone feels that a tyrant is needed. But in fact, even if a tyrant appears now, the tyrant has no way to accurately distinguish between white lotus and saintly bitches. At that time, there will only be indiscriminate attacks, and another axis country will appear. If technology develops in the future, humans can be screened out from the good and the bad at birth, then there will be opportunities for tyrants to display their talents." Duran said that even if the 'Philosopher King' appears, the current social productivity cannot fully display his wisdom.
The Philosopher King is a thousand-mile horse, and productivity is a Bole. Without Bole, there is no thousand-mile horse.
The girl was thoughtful. After being with Duran for a long time, she had to study hard to keep up with Duran's pace. She was only fourteen, but she now had a special way of learning, which was to enter the scholar's dream and let the scholar teach her. In this way, her knowledge level has been improving.
"But if productivity has increased, do we really need a tyrant? Why not let a kind person rule?" The girl was really smart.
"Yes, this is the flaw of this expert. He thinks that only killers can complete the work, but good people can also complete it. It's just that good people will hesitate, but as long as good people have normal IQ and can judge the pros and cons, they can also complete the task." Of course, unless it is like in "Psychometrics", the killer's brain is needed as a benchmark to judge other people's crime index, and the killer's brain is indispensable, otherwise it is really not necessary to have a killer. It can only be said that if the killer is allowed to rule the country, the killer can also be blamed, and ordinary people don't have to take the risk of being responsible and bearing the infamy.
The girl despised the expert even more: "What kind of person is this? He talks a lot like castles in the air, but completely ignores reality."
"This is philosophy. Philosophy always assumes an ideal state and rational people, so it is difficult for philosophy to become experience. It can only be used as a general direction, but not as a governing philosophy." Duran told the girl that this is knowledge, this is theory, and there is a huge gap between it and practice.
The girl also nodded: "The knowledge learned by scholars comes from books, and the people who write books are also scholars. This is passed down from generation to generation by scholars. They have no chance to go deep into society. No wonder they are all castles in the air." "If I read in the future, I will definitely read more books written by people who have gone deep into society." The girl believes that these books are not only wisdom but also experience.